Giant Robo: The Day The Earth Stood Still
Someone suggested this to me so I decided to go old school and take a peak. Without knowing the characters I lost about 10% of the thrill, but it was still really great to watch. I can see how it must have been popular back when the original aired, they really know how to make things action packed.
Needless
Too short, bad characters, plot kind of sucked. I mostly regret watching it.
Toaru Majutsu no Index
This was clearly a well thought out series. Even minor characters are well thought out, and the concept is really great. I love characters with unbeatable powers who also get their butt kicked. It ended sort of abruptly, so i'm really looking forward to seeing more.
Spice And Wolf II
Spice and Wolf I, only more of it. Which is not a bad thing.
Tears To Tiara

Kind of a vague reference to Camelot and King Arthur. It could have been very good, but it wasn't intense enough so i'd call it only ok. My favorite kind of anime is one of domain and power expansion, but in this case they really didn't do anything with their power and just hung out alone on an island. Boring.
Black Jack

Again I tried to go retro, this series is so widely known so how could it not be good? Well guess what, it wasn't good. It was just surgery after surgery with no real plot development. I'm not really one to watch something if it's not going to go anywhere.
Darker Than Black II
Not even half as good as the first one, and although a very interesting new character was added it didn't make up for what they did to the old ones. Some died, some personalities changed too much, and overall it wasn't worth it. They should have just found a way to continue with the original story. Also the ending was ridiculously dumb.
Eve no Jikan
This was short, but very very good. The idea of robots and humans trying to coexist gave me a tingle, and I eagerly watched each episode to see what would happen. I just wish it was longer, I wouldn't have minded a full series of this. I hope they make more soon....
Junjou Romantica
.......what? I heard it was good. People recommended it to me. Sure it's full of boys love, but the characters and plot are pretty solid. The voice actors are great, and familiar if you know them well enough. Although there are a lot of sex scenes I had to skip through ultimately it was a lot of fun to watch. It's romantic and funny and sometimes sad at the same time. There was a second story arc mixed in that I just plain skipped though. I was into the main characters, not some other plot that kept confusing me. So I feel like I only got to see half a series, oh well it was worth it.
Kino's Journey
I had almost watched this when it premiered but I was too busy with school at the time, so I went back and watched it. It's a very original concept, and it was really interesting to watch. But for my personal tastes, at least for this series, it was far far far too dark. A lot of bad things happened to good people and I really didn't like that.
Kurokami
I actually had read this manga a little before it was an anime, so I was looking forward to seeing this adaption. Unfortunately it wasn't spectacular. The plot was alright and the characters were alright but none of it was really great or anything. The ending was a bit dumb as well.
Nogizaka Haruka No Himitsu 2
Just as good as the first, so watch it.
Puchi Puri Yuushi
I don't even know why I downloaded this, but it was worth the time. It was a really cute fairy tale story about princesses, which normally is not my thing, but it had a bit of action and romance to spice things up as well as some comedy. I wouldn't take it as a very serious series but I definitely had fun with it.
Queens Blade
Half nude lesbians with weapons..............yup.
History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi
Definitely one of my favorite series of the bunch. It reminded me a lot of Air Master, only it made more sense and had stronger characters. The martial arts masters were all very in depth characters, and the plot was well thought out. Even the side characters were fun to watch (I always laughed when Ziegfried appeared). My only problem with the story was this really annoying guy who pretended to be Kenichi's friend. Besides that it was a really great series, I could have watched another season easily.
Sky Girls

Cute girls fighting monsters with robots, how can that be bad? There was a small plot hole with the main characters brother that didn't really make sense, but overall it was worth the time to watch. I'm glad they kept it short though, I think too many episodes would have killed it.
Skip Beat

Although it sounded really lame when I decided to download it the fact is that this has become one of my favorite series. After I watched the anime I even went and red the next hundred chapters of the manga because I wasn't satisfied. Each character is memorable, each episode is good, and the plot is extremely original and well thought out. If I only had to watch one of these again i'd make it Skip Beat. The worst part is that I downloaded the soundtrack and all the good songs are by that bastard Fuwa Shou.......